On a friend's recommendation, Jim picked up The Hunger
Games for his train commute the other day, finished it in a flash and suggested
I give it a try. Now, we've both
finished all three books in the series and really liked them, mostly.
(Spoiler alert: I’ll be careful to divulge as little of
the plot as possible, in case you haven’t read the books and want to, but there
will be a wee bit of revealing commentary I can’t help.)
Riding in the car with Jim
yesterday, we started talking about the ending in the third book, Mockingjay,
how it feels rushed and truncated to both of us. In Jim’s words, it lacks a real denouement.
We suppose the author could
have been under pressure to deliver the copy or in a hurry to wrap up the
story, but I want to know how hope, trust and love were reborn from the ashes
of Katniss and Peeta’s shattered lives. How did they get from trauma, horror
and loss to a life together in what’s left of district 12?
For me, Peeta is the most
spiritual character in the story; he reminds me of the Fool in the Tarot deck,
loving, trusting and joyful. He’s
capable of complete self-sacrifice in the name of love; yet, in the end, after
going through hell and back, his story is summarized in a matter of a few
paragraphs spoken by Katniss in her closing narrative.
The same goes for Katniss; so
many wounds and so much fire in her soul, and her journey back to relative
sanity is hardly described at all. Yes, she relays how she grieved for one
person she lost, but did Peeta’s love once again restore her? Isn’t this worth some of the
descriptive artistry the author devotes to earlier parts of their relationship,
like say, in book one?
True there was nothing left
to blow up or kill by the time Katniss is narrating the end of the story, but
how did they arrive at the point where they could have a life together? It’s a story of healing and
restoration; was it love that gave them back a life? Did one rescue the other
from the brink, only to be rescued as well in the process? This part of the story is worth many
more pages, not just a short paragraph or two. I don’t know why it ends so abruptly, but I’m sure Suzanne
Collins could do a great job of fleshing it out. Well, there’s still the movie script to the third book…
I admit I have a problem with
“the future is bleak” story lines like this one. Big Brother always watches; there’s always lots of cruelty,
violence and loss. I know there
are many examples of this scenario in history and in some parts of the
contemporary world, but is this the only future we can imagine winning out,
becoming the outcome of our present age?
While we can dream, is this the best we can do?
If these are the fictions that entertain us, I think
at some level it sets us up to anticipate this future; our sights/sites are
set, both our vision and its scope, on the joyless, the dismal, the dire, the
horror and the tragic in life. It
pumps us full of survival adrenalin, but it gives us nothing to hope for. I remember leaving the theater after
seeing Clockwork Orange many years ago, and asking; Where’s the Love? Who in
this story embodied that human potential?
I don’t see Suzanne Collin’s trilogy as devoid of human
caring; in fact, I think love is constantly displayed between various
characters. The power of Love to
transcend incredible odds is often woven into the story, but in the end, that’s
exactly what’s left out, zip, zap, done.
In the last book, Peeta, who
suffers severe PTS and paranoia as a result of being tortured, devises a way to
test for trustworthiness in those around him. He recounts a memory and asks,
“Real or Not Real?” His question
elicits wonderful heartfelt responses from those trying to help him. I think it’s a good question to ask.
The Hunger Games Trilogy:
Real or Not Real?
The love between the
characters: Real or Not Real?
Love heals: Real or Not Real?
Love is the answer: Real or
Not Real?
We can dream a future story
that doesn’t involve total catastrophe, loss and destruction: Real or Not Real?
Dreams are Real: Real or Not
Real? You know my answer to that
one.